Best Eye Doctors In Middletown, NY

Why trust us?

VisionCenter is committed to connecting patients to the best local healthcare providers. We reviewed 78 Optometrists in Middletown, NY, and chose this list based on their:

  • Qualifications and education
  • Years of experience
  • Reputation and resources
  • Past customer experiences

We used AI technology to analyze 13854 reviews from Google, Yelp, and Facebook to find patients' favorite surgeons in the area. Our team then went through and hand picked our list of the best Optometrists in Middletown.


1 Galleria Dr #26, Middletown, NY 10941

4.9 out of 5 (468 reviews)


The eye care center in Middletown has received positive reviews for their expedited service and helpful staff. Customers appreciate the assistance of eye doctors like Vicky and Karalyn in guiding them towards getting an eye exam and selecting the perfect frames. Donna, the manager, is also praised for her warm and welcoming demeanor, as well as her assistance in finding the right glasses. Overall, the center is recommended for its friendly and efficient service.


  • Expedited service for DOT drivers in need of glasses.
  • Friendly and helpful staff, including Donna and Karalyn.
  • Easy and pleasant experience for eye exams and finding frames.

Park Professional Eyecare

1250 Pelham Pkwy S, Bronx, NY 10461

4.9 out of 5 (378 reviews)


The reviews for this eye care center are overwhelmingly positive. Customers praise the outstanding customer service, short waiting times, and thorough eye examinations provided by Dr. Paternoster. The office is described as clean and modern, and the staff is highly professional and helpful in assisting with selecting glasses. Overall, customers highly recommend this eye care center.


  • Outstanding customer service and no waiting time at the front desk.
  • Thorough and complete eye exams performed by Dr. Paternoster.
  • Modern, clean office with state-of-the-art equipment and a wide selection of glasses.

Eye D Vision Eye Care & OrthoK

2071 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11214

4.8 out of 5 (356 reviews)


Overall, the majority of reviews for the eye care center are positive. Customers appreciate the friendly and accommodating staff, from the front desk to the eye doctors. Many reviewers mention the thoroughness of the eye exams and the ability to ask questions and receive helpful advice. There are also mentions of a good selection of frames and a relaxed and clean environment. However, there is one negative review mentioning issues with incorrect lens installation and inaccurate prescriptions.


  • Friendly and professional staff: Multiple reviews mention the staff being friendly, accommodating, and attentive during the eye exam process. This creates a positive and comfortable experience for patients.
  • Transparent pricing: Several reviews appreciate that the prices for services are clearly stated upfront, allowing patients to budget accordingly and avoid any surprise bills at the end of their visit.
  • Thorough and knowledgeable doctors: There are multiple mentions of the doctors being thorough, patient, and informative during the eye exams. Patients appreciate the attention to detail and the willingness of the doctors to answer questions and provide advice on eye health.

eye&I | Bayside

39-25 Bell Blvd, Bayside, NY 11361

4.8 out of 5 (315 reviews)


Customers praise the eye care center for its thorough and educational eye exams, as well as the clean and welcoming environment. The doctors and staff are commended for their professionalism, knowledge, and friendly demeanor. Some customers had issues with unexpected additional charges for certain procedures, but overall, the majority of reviews recommend the eye care center for comprehensive eye exams and glasses purchases.


  • Thorough eye exams: Multiple reviews mention that the doctors at this eye care center take their time to perform comprehensive and thorough eye exams. They explain everything in detail and provide education about maintaining healthy eyes.
  • Knowledgeable and professional staff: The staff at this eye care center are described as friendly, approachable, and professional. They go above and beyond to help customers find the right frames and provide excellent customer service throughout the entire process.
  • Clean and modern facilities: Many reviews highlight the cleanliness and modernity of the facilities. The eye care center is commended for having new machines and equipment, creating a pleasant and comfortable environment for patients.

Cohen's Fashion Optical

1 Galleria Dr, Middletown, NY 10941

4.1 out of 5 (250 reviews)


The first review mentions a long wait time and ultimately leaving without being seen. The second and third reviews praise the staff and eye doctors for their kindness and professionalism. The fourth and sixth reviews express satisfaction with the service and the ability to see properly with new glasses. The fifth review highlights the positive experiences at the Galleria Mall location. The seventh review mentions the great service and quick pick-up. The eighth review emphasizes the friendly staff and pleasant experience. The ninth review expresses gratitude for the prompt and excellent service. The tenth review compliments the staff and treatment received during the eye exam. The eleventh review praises the kindness and efficiency of the staff, especially during a busy time. The twelfth review appreciates the timely assistance and stress-free experience. The thirteenth review mentions the positive interactions with the doctor and staff, as well as the willingness to address issues and provide replacements. The fourteenth review expresses disappointment with the online appointment system and lack of customer service response. The fifteenth review details a negative experience with a procedure for dry eyes. The sixteenth review highlights the helpfulness and knowledge of the staff, as well as the thoroughness of the eye exam. The seventeenth review mentions the positive experience with quick service, helpfulness, and affordability. The eighteenth review discusses issues with frame replacement and dissatisfaction with plastic frames.


  • Friendly and helpful staff: Multiple reviews mention the staff being kind, welcoming, and providing excellent customer service. They are described as being courteous, professional, and knowledgeable, making patients feel comfortable during their eye exams and frame selections.
  • Thorough and persistent eye exams: Several reviewers mention that they received the most thorough eye exam they have ever experienced at this location. The optometrists are praised for their persistence in ensuring accurate prescriptions and thorough examinations.
  • Prompt and efficient service: Many reviewers mention receiving prompt and efficient service, even during busy times. Some even express surprise at how quickly they received their glasses or had their eye exams done. This suggests that the staff at this location are able to handle busy periods and still provide timely service.

Eye & Health

159 1st Ave., New York, NY 10003

4.4 out of 5 (207 reviews)


The majority of reviews about Eye & Health are positive, with customers praising the knowledgeable and efficient doctors, friendly staff, and convenient location. Many reviewers mentioned that they had been going to the center for years and have been consistently satisfied with the service. However, there are a few negative reviews that mention issues with incorrect billing and rude staff. Overall, the center seems to offer a positive experience for eye exams and eyewear.


  • Knowledgeable and efficient doctors
  • Friendly and accommodating staff
  • Great selection of eye frames

Fusion Eyewear: Designer Eyewear For Less

130 Dolson Ave STE 108, Middletown, NY 10940

5 out of 5 (157 reviews)


Fusion Eyewear receives consistently positive reviews for their eye doctors and eye exam places. Reviewers praise the fast service, professionalism, and exceptional customer service provided by Orlando, Barbara, and Dr. Craig Nathanson. Many customers mention the wide selection of designer frames, affordable prices, and the ability to get glasses the same day. Overall, Fusion Eyewear is highly recommended for all eyewear needs.


  • Quick and efficient service: Multiple reviewers mentioned that they were impressed by the speed at which the eye exams were conducted and the glasses were made. Some even received their new glasses on the same day.
  • Excellent customer service: Reviewers consistently mentioned the helpfulness and friendliness of the staff, particularly highlighting the assistance provided by Barbara and Orlando. Customers felt well taken care of and appreciated the personalized attention they received.
  • Wide selection of frames: Several reviewers mentioned the impressive range of designer frames available at Fusion Eyewear. Customers were able to find the perfect frames for their style and preferences.

Ultimate Spectacle

125 Dolson Ave, Middletown, NY 10940

4.4 out of 5 (157 reviews)


Customers had overwhelmingly positive experiences at the eye care center. They praised the friendly and knowledgeable staff, thorough eye exams, and personalized attention to finding the right frames and lenses. Customers appreciated the exceptional customer service and felt valued throughout the process.


  • Excellent customer service: Multiple reviews mention the helpfulness and patience of the staff, particularly Maria, in assisting with frame selection and explaining different lens options.
  • Thorough and knowledgeable eye exams: Reviews consistently praise the doctors for providing thorough and detailed eye exams, addressing both visual needs and overall eye health concerns. Dr. Guttman and Dr. Kahle are specifically mentioned as being knowledgeable and caring.
  • Friendly and welcoming atmosphere: Many reviews mention the friendly and welcoming environment at the eye care center, making patients feel comfortable and at ease during their visit. The staff is described as kind, knowledgeable, and patient.

Paula Ulmer OD

176 Greenwich Ave, Goshen, NY 10924

4.8 out of 5 (75 reviews)


Dr. Ulmer and her staff at the eye care center are highly recommended for their excellent service and professionalism. Patients appreciate Dr. Ulmer's thoroughness and personable manner during eye exams. However, there is a complaint about a delay in receiving glasses and lack of follow-up on a prescription issue, which has caused frustration for one patient. Overall, Dr. Ulmer's practice is praised for their friendly staff, efficient service, and quality eye care.


  • Dr. Ulmer and her staff are highly recommended for their excellent service and making patients, including children, feel comfortable during eye exams.
  • Dr. Ulmer is known for her thoroughness, professionalism, and personable nature, making the eye care experience pleasant for patients.
  • The office staff is praised for their professionalism, kindness, and attention to patient needs, ensuring a positive overall experience.

Adult and Pediatric Eyecare

200 Midway Park Dr # 1, Middletown, NY 10940

4.7 out of 5 (79 reviews)


Dr. Lake and his colleagues at this eye care center are highly recommended for eye exams. Customers have praised the thoroughness of the exams and the professionalism of the doctors. Some reviews mention that the staff could use improvement in customer service, but overall, the experience at this eye care center is described as exceptional and the office is praised for its friendly and accommodating atmosphere.


  • Dr. Lake and his colleagues are highly recommended by multiple reviewers, signaling their professionalism and expertise in eye exams and eye care.
  • The office staff is friendly, accommodating, and helpful, creating a pleasant and welcoming atmosphere for patients.
  • The eye care center offers thorough and comprehensive exams, using a variety of tests to ensure all aspects of eye health are addressed.

Riehle Optician of Warwick Inc.

104 Main St, Warwick, NY 10990

4.9 out of 5 (60 reviews)


Customers consistently praise Riehle Opticians for their exceptional customer service, professional and thorough eye exams, and large selection of high-quality eyewear. The staff, including Optometrists Dr. Lee Podberosky and Dr. George Zikos, as well as sales associates Lilly and Michelle, are highly praised for their knowledge, care, and personable approach. Many customers have found the perfect pair of glasses with their guidance and appreciate the personalized attention and patience they received throughout the selection process. Overall, customers highly recommend Riehle Opticians for their expertise, service, and friendly atmosphere.


  • Professional and accommodating staff, providing thorough eye exams with informative and caring optometrists.
  • Large selection of the latest eyewear, with helpful guidance from the staff to ensure customers find the perfect frames.
  • Excellent customer service, with personalized attention and a friendly atmosphere.
Vision Center Logo
The information provided on should not be used in place of actual information provided by a doctor or a specialist.
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram