Best Eye Doctors In Commack, NY

Why trust us?

VisionCenter is committed to connecting patients to the best local healthcare providers. We reviewed 130 Optometrists in Commack, NY, and chose this list based on their:

  • Qualifications and education
  • Years of experience
  • Reputation and resources
  • Past customer experiences

We used AI technology to analyze 14309 reviews from Google, Yelp, and Facebook to find patients' favorite surgeons in the area. Our team then went through and hand picked our list of the best Optometrists in Commack.

SightMD Brentwood Suffolk Ave

601 Suffolk Ave, Brentwood, NY 11717

4.5 out of 5 (826 reviews)


Overall, the reviews are mostly positive with praise for the professionalism, knowledgeable staff, and attentive doctors at the eye care center. Some negative reviews mention issues with communication and long wait times, particularly at the Brentwood location. However, there are also positive reviews praising specific doctors, such as Dr. Sarwal and Dr. Marcus, for their expertise and successful procedures.


  • Professional and knowledgeable staff: Many reviewers praised the staff members for their professionalism and expertise in providing eye care and conducting thorough eye exams.
  • Accommodating emergency appointments: Several reviewers mentioned that the eye care center made time to see them for emergency appointments, even without a prior appointment. They appreciated the dedication and helpfulness of the staff in such situations.
  • High-quality eye surgery results: One reviewer specifically praised Dr. Sarwal for performing perfect cataract surgery, as confirmed by another eye doctor. This highlights the center's ability to provide successful and delicate eye surgeries.

OCLI Vision Huntington (E Jericho)

1700 E Jericho Turnpike, Huntington, NY 11743

4.8 out of 5 (565 reviews)


The majority of the reviews express frustration with the long wait times and difficulty in scheduling appointments at this eye care center. Some patients had to resort to visiting the office in person to make an appointment. However, some reviewers were impressed with the thoroughness and professionalism of the doctors and staff, especially with their ability to handle complex eye conditions and surgeries. There were also positive mentions about the friendly and courteous staff, as well as the quick and efficient eye examinations.


  • Thorough and professional eye exams performed by knowledgeable doctors and technicians.
  • Friendly and courteous staff who genuinely care about their patients' wellbeing.
  • Highly skilled and experienced doctors who have a track record of successful surgeries, giving patients confidence and trust in their care.

SightMD Hauppauge

110 Marcus Blvd Suite 400, Hauppauge, NY 11788

4.6 out of 5 (338 reviews)


One reviewer had a negative experience, feeling rushed during their eye exam and encountering issues with their prescription. Another reviewer had a bad experience with billing and being sent a bill for an out-of-network visit. However, several reviewers had positive experiences, praising the courteous and knowledgeable staff, minimal wait times, and professionalism of the doctors. Some reviewers specifically mentioned the excellence of certain doctors and efficient practices.


  • Courteous and helpful staff who are knowledgeable and willing to find answers.
  • Proficient and well-organized office with minimal wait times.
  • Doctors who are professional, attentive, and knowledgeable.

Dr. Brett J. Rosenblatt, M.D. VitreoRetinal Consulants

200 Motor Pkwy Suite A-2, Hauppauge, NY 11788

5 out of 5 (226 reviews)


Dr. Rosenblatt is highly regarded by patients for his thoroughness, professionalism, and attentiveness. The staff at the eye care center is praised for their friendliness, efficiency, and helpfulness. Despite being busy, the office maintains a professional and safe environment. Overall, patients highly recommend Dr. Rosenblatt and the practice for their excellent care and patient-centered approach.


  • Dr. Rosenblatt is a top-notch doctor who takes the time to discuss wellness, test results, and treatments.
  • The staff is friendly, helpful, and caring, providing excellent patient care.
  • The practice is professional, efficient, and attentive to detail, with a focus on maintaining the patient's sight.

Stahl Eyecare Experts - Hauppauge Office

200 Motor Pkwy Suite D-25, Hauppauge, NY 11788

4.8 out of 5 (191 reviews)


Overall, the positive reviews of the eye care center highlight the professionalism and kindness of the staff, as well as the thoroughness of the doctors. Many reviewers were pleased with the level of care and attention they received during their eye exams and procedures. Some specific mentions were made about the knowledgeable and friendly staff, the state-of-the-art office, and successful cataract surgeries.


  • Friendly and professional staff
  • State-of-the-art equipment and thorough eye exams
  • Caring and knowledgeable doctors for Lasik and cataract surgeries

SightMD Brentwood

1758 Brentwood Rd, Brentwood, NY 11717

4.8 out of 5 (190 reviews)


Customers highly recommend Dr. Vivian Renta at SightMD for eye care services. She is knowledgeable, professional, and provides excellent care. The staff is friendly and welcoming, and the overall experience is positive. The office is efficient and takes proper COVID precautions. Some customers had minor issues with a rude staff member, but the overall consensus is that the doctor and the rest of the staff are courteous and attentive.


  • Dr. Vivian Renta is highly recommended for addressing dry eyes and providing effective solutions like plugs and optase spray.
  • The staff is welcoming, friendly, and knowledgeable, providing a great experience for both adults and children.
  • The office is professional, with easy online appointment scheduling, minimal wait times, and thorough examinations.

Professional Optometry Vision Care

77 Veterans Memorial Hwy #6, Commack, NY 11725

4.9 out of 5 (155 reviews)


The majority of reviews for Professional Optometry Vision Care and its eye doctors are extremely positive. Patients appreciate the friendly and helpful staff, as well as the thorough and efficient eye exams. Dr. Valle and Dr. Ferraro are specifically mentioned as being knowledgeable, professional, and caring. The office is described as clean and equipped with state-of-the-art equipment. Overall, patients highly recommend this eye care center for excellent service and top-notch eye care.


  • Friendly and professional staff: The reviews consistently mention the friendly and professional staff at this eye care center. Patients feel welcomed and comfortable during their visit.
  • Thorough and efficient eye exams: Multiple reviews mention that the eye exams at this center are thorough and efficient. Doctors take their time to explain everything and answer any questions, ensuring patients feel well taken care of.
  • Knowledgeable and caring doctors: The doctors at this eye care center are described as knowledgeable, caring, and attentive. They listen to patients' concerns and provide detailed feedback, creating a positive and reassuring experience.

Exclusive Eyewear

6122 Jericho Turnpike, Commack, NY 11725

5 out of 5 (114 reviews)


Customers have had excellent experiences at Exclusive Eyewear, praising the professionalism and knowledge of the owner, Mark. They highly recommend the store for its great selection of frames, fair pricing, fast turnaround time, and personalized service. Customers appreciate Mark's patience, honesty, and willingness to go above and beyond in ensuring customer satisfaction.


  • Mark, the optician/owner, is professional, knowledgeable, patient, and provides excellent customer service.
  • Exclusive Eyewear has a great selection of both designer and non-designer frames for men, women, and children.
  • The store offers fast turnaround time for glasses, with some customers receiving their new glasses in just a few days.
  • Mark offers fair pricing and is willing to customize lenses for rimless frames.
  • Customers appreciate the modern and clean store environment at Exclusive Eyewear.
  • The store prioritizes customer satisfaction and is willing to go above and beyond to fix any issues.
  • Mark has a great eye for detail and can recommend frames that compliment the customer's face.
  • The store provides a wide variety of unique eyewear options.
  • Mark is known for his friendly and professional demeanor, making the shopping experience enjoyable.
  • Exclusive Eyewear supports small local businesses and provides a level of service and care that big chain stores may lack.

Lux Eye Care Studio: Tracy Brooks, OD

1946 Jericho Turnpike, East Northport, NY 11731

4.9 out of 5 (88 reviews)


The Lux Eye Care Studio is highly praised for its exceptional customer service and qualified professionals. Customers rave about the thorough and knowledgeable eye exams conducted by Dr. Brooks, and appreciate the patience and assistance provided in finding the perfect frames. The studio is described as clean, modern, and fashionable, with a wide selection of frames to choose from, making it a top recommendation for eye care needs.


  • Highly knowledgeable and thorough eye exams: Multiple reviews praise Dr. Brooks for providing thorough and detailed eye exams, ensuring accurate prescriptions and addressing any concerns or medical conditions related to the eyes.
  • Patient and helpful staff: Reviewers mention the patience and guidance provided by the staff at Lux Eye Care Studio, particularly when helping customers try on frames and choose the perfect pair of glasses.
  • Extensive selection of frames: The eye care center is praised for its wide variety of trendy and fashionable frames, allowing customers to find glasses that suit their style and preferences.

Aspects Eyecare

812 Wheeler Rd Suite 106, Hauppauge, NY 11788

5 out of 5 (59 reviews)


Aspects Eyecare is highly recommended by customers for their excellent service, attentive staff, and convenient location. The eye doctors, particularly Dr. Irina, are praised for their professionalism, thoroughness, and personalized approach to eye care. The office is described as clean, modern, and welcoming, with a wide selection of stylish eyewear. Overall, customers are impressed with the level of care and expertise they receive at Aspects Eyecare.


  • Excellent service: The staff at Aspects Eyecare provide top-notch service, with many reviewers praising their attentiveness and helpfulness. They make scheduling easy and assist in choosing the perfect pair of glasses.
  • Knowledgeable and thorough eye exams: Reviewers appreciate the comprehensive and understandable eye exams conducted by the optometrists at Aspects Eyecare. The doctors take the time to explain procedures, findings, and treatment options, ensuring that patients feel involved in their eye care.
  • Welcoming atmosphere and personalized approach: The clinic at Aspects Eyecare is described as welcoming and comfortable. The staff remembers patients' specific eye care needs, tailoring each visit to the individual. Additionally, the personalized approach extends to aftercare and follow-ups, ensuring patients' comfort and providing expert advice on maintaining eye health.

Dr. Theodore Devore, Optometrist, and Associates - Commack

6401 Jericho Turnpike, Commack, NY 11725

4.9 out of 5 (63 reviews)


The majority of the reviews for this eye care center are positive, with customers praising the kind and helpful staff, the thorough and pleasant eye exams, and the ease of scheduling appointments. However, there is one negative review where a customer felt the doctor was arrogant and rushed the eye exam. Overall, the office staff and doctors are highly recommended for their professionalism, knowledge, and courteousness.


  • The staff is described as wonderful, kind, friendly, and helpful.
  • The optometrist is personable, thorough, and provides a pleasant and informative eye exam experience.
  • The office staff is efficient, professional, and courteous, ensuring minimal wait times and a seamless appointment process.
Vision Center Logo
The information provided on should not be used in place of actual information provided by a doctor or a specialist.
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram